Skip to content
Local SEO guides

Best-of lists: how to get on them, and why they matter now

Which roundups are worth a pitch, and how to see which ones AI answers cite in your town.

Search "best dentist in [your town]" and you'll usually find a few articles from local news sites and city blogs near the top. Those are best-of lists. A spot on one puts your name in front of people who are already comparing their options.

Someone writes each of these lists, usually a local reporter, a city blogger or an editor at an industry site. You can pitch a person. A spot on the right list can also help your own local SEO, which makes a few emails worth sending.

Why best-of lists are worth your time

A mention on a respected local site can help in two ways. If it lists your name, address and phone, it also works as a local citation. It may come with a link back to your website as well. Google says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity, and that how many websites link to you is part of popularity.

AI search is the newer reason. Ask ChatGPT "who's the best electrician near me" and you'll often get a short list of names, sometimes with links to the pages it drew on. Neither Google nor OpenAI explains how its AI chooses which businesses to name. You can see what an answer cites, though. AI answers often cite "best of" articles and directories, so ask ChatGPT yourself and look at the sources it lists. Any local roundup that turns up there goes near the top of your pitch list. Our guide on showing up in AI search covers the rest.

SEO Retriever's AI Visibility module checks once a month how often ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode name your business or cite your site.

How to find the lists that matter

Search the way your customers do. A plumbing company might try "best plumber in [your city]" and "emergency plumber [city] reviews." A dental practice might try "best family dentist [city]." Write down every article on the first page or two. They already rank, so they're the ones customers see. Then ask ChatGPT the same questions and add any list it cites. Skip obscure directories nobody visits.

Note who publishes each one. A local newspaper, an established city or neighborhood blog, and a well-known industry publication are worth the effort. A thin "award" site you've never heard of usually isn't, especially if it asks for a fee up front.

How to earn a spot

  1. Make yourself an easy yes. If a writer looks you up, your Google profile is probably the first thing they see. A complete profile with plenty of real reviews makes you look like a safe pick. If yours is thin, start by asking every customer for a review and filling in the rest of your profile.
  2. Reach out to the publishers. Many local lists get updated from time to time, and the writer may be open to suggestions. Send a short email about why customers in your area trust you, like your years in business, a specialty or your review rating. Some city sites and industry roundups take direct submissions.
  3. Give them something to point to. A clear website, real photos and a track record make you easy to recommend. The same work that helps your website rank locally also makes you a credible name to list.
  4. Earn mentions the natural way too. Sponsoring a local team, supporting a community event or doing work people talk about can lead to write-ups and links. That's the heart of local link building.

A few things to avoid

Skip pay-to-play "best of" badges from sites you've never heard of. They tend to send few customers, and anyone who looks closely can see the spot was bought. Don't chase lists for cities you don't serve, either. A mention in a town you don't cover brings calls you can't take. Go after recommendations in the places your customers already look.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get my business on a "best of" list?

Find the lists that already rank for your service and town by searching "best [your service] in [your city]." Then contact the people who write them. Local news sites, city blogs and industry roundups often take suggestions. Get your Google profile complete before you reach out, because a writer will likely look you up there.

Can I pay to be on a best-of list?

Some directories and "award" sites sell placement. Those spots usually do little for you, and readers can often tell they were bought. Put your effort into lists from local newspapers, established city blogs and industry publications, where a real person decided you were worth recommending.

Do best-of lists help my Google ranking?

They can. If a list links to your website, that's one more site linking to you, and Google says links feed into popularity, one of the factors local results are mainly based on. If the list shows your name, address and phone, it also works as a citation.

Get more local customers from Google and AI search

SEO Retriever is an all-in-one tool. It shows where you come up on Google Maps, in search, and in AI answers from ChatGPT and Google. It checks your reviews, Business Profile, and website as well. Then you get a prioritized to-do list of what to fix first. Free for 14 days. No credit card required.

Start Free Trial